PasswordSignInAsync Fails, What Next?
# help-with-umbracom
Mark Drake
08/06/2024, 7:04 PMI have an Umbraco Form for members to fill out and register on the site. There is a workflow attached which will create a member using the email and password.
(The member is created successfully.)
And after the form submission, I can use the email address and password to sign in.
So I'm trying to save our members a step by signing them in automatically.... and no matter what I try the
IMemberSignInManagerr
Rachel D
08/06/2024, 7:25 PMSounds like the member might not be getting saved fully before you try to sign in, could you try using two separate scopes and perhaps adding a short wait between them?
m
Matt Wise
08/06/2024, 7:36 PMHave you closed your scope so the transaction can complete for the creation?
m
Mark Drake
08/06/2024, 7:46 PMThanks for the reply @Rachel D
A few things I tried:
- async wait for the member to create
- using the "CreateMemberWithIdentity" because the docs mention it persisting before being returned
- I put in a large delay (thread.sleep) but I'm not sure if that is a good way of testing
Separating the scopes - I will try that next. I assume I can wrap the member creation step in a using statement, and the member sign in statement with a new using statement to accomplish this?
(FED if you can't tell. Thanks so much for your help too Matt.)
Mark Drake
08/06/2024, 7:58 PMI tried opening and closing scopes around the two (both are being done as part of the form workflow - create the user, assign the password, and now my attempt to sign in)
I tried to use another method which signs in a user with MemberIdentityUser and this at least bubbled up an error.
But I happen to be on a Mac and Rider won't let me step into external methods like this. It looks like perhaps there is something "unfinished" with the claims?
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1270457524881199296/1270471150442516631/image.png?ex=66b3d1f6&is=66b28076&hm=9b899774ace1dc32524f5a968f210382fb4dfe599ae9dc8c753d5f2f5577a398&
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1270457524881199296/1270471150748696697/image.png?ex=66b3d1f6&is=66b28076&hm=c15ecf1a9aec21b65cf4beb7393eb2e6c20693cab8c551fe3a7ee53d9d6e9ea3&
https://cdn.discordapp.com/attachments/1270457524881199296/1270471151100891266/image.png?ex=66b3d1f6&is=66b28076&hm=e30d793578c6a25358e3dda865381bdcb996644c93a9ab872df2673605be9537&
Mark Drake
08/07/2024, 12:45 AMTo fix my issue I did the following:
- Replaced
_memberService.CreateMemberWithIdentityMemberIdentityUser.CreateNew_memberManager.CreateAsyncCreateNewMark Drake
08/07/2024, 12:48 AMThis also solves some sillyness I had to do to request a password reset token to set the actual password. All around improvements.
Mark Drake
08/07/2024, 12:50 AM Copy code
var identityUser = MemberIdentityUser.CreateNew(
email,
email,
memberType.Alias,
true,
$"{firstName} {lastName}");
var identityResult = await _memberManager.CreateAsync(identityUser, password);
if (identityResult.Succeeded)
{
IMember? member = _memberService.GetByKey(identityUser.Key);
member.SetValue("firstName", firstName);
member.SetValue("lastName", lastName);
_memberService.Save(member);
await _signInManager.SignInAsync(identityUser, false);
}50 Views